My view of this is that this is a big historical change and they tend to be messy and difficult and violent and, inside, contradictory. On the one hand, positive things are going on; on the other hand, quite negative things are going on. It’s just the way historical changes [are made]. I’ve been reading over the summer biographies of the Founding Fathers. By all accounts, the United States of America should never have come into being. First of all, they were fighting the greatest power of the times militarily and in terms of reach. -- Condoleezza Rice on Iraq, Newsweek
In the late 1700s, the burgeoning United States was fighting off "the greatest power of the times militarily and in terms of reach"--the British Empire. But the Iraqi resistance is presently fighting off the greatest military power of its era--the U.S. Empire. Funny how things have changed. In fact, these historical changes clearly disprove Condoleezza Rice's analogy of Iraq to the nascent United States.
Condi's comparison of the emergence of Iraqi democracy to the Founding Fathers and the formation of American democracy falls flat on its face. In 1776, a foreign power did not sail to the shores of Virginia, invade the region and then expel British forces from the colonies. Rather, the complete opposite happened. The colonists formed a homegrown insurgency, overthrew the ruling regime themselves (albeit with some French military assistance later on) and then formed their own unique, independent form of government.
If we are to swallow Condi's analogy then she must believe in an entirely different version of the American Revolution. Imagine this. French troops invade the colonies and liberate the colonists from King George III's colonial regime. Once the British forces are driven out of power the French install a provisional government which is headed by a young rich Cardinal. This Cardinal purges loyalists from the government, takes over the rum, cotton and tobacco industries, abolishes English common law, and then puts a gun to the head of George Washington and says "you are free, now adopt a French style of government or die, you stinking piece of merde!" If this actually took place, I think the United States would have turned out very differently.
The whole idea of forcing people to adopt democratic government is ludicrous. Democratic government should not be imposed, it should be homegrown, that is, develop naturally out of conditions unique to the culture and traditions of the region. The American colonies had developed a long tradition of democratic values with town hall meetings and local involvement. This spawned a culture which was highly conducive to forming a republic of representative government. What is Iraq's experience with democracy? Non-existent. Right now Iraq is ruled by a puppet regime whose strings are deeply frayed and will soon be cut by a full-blown civil war. One might say, "but we created democracy in Germany and Japan after World War II". True. The Marshall Plan was ambitious, well-led, well-funded and well-executed. The Rumsfeld plan for Iraq was, uh, did they even have a plan? I don't think so.
Let's get back to Condi for a second. This weekend, the Madame Secretary was too busy to attend a dinner with other female foreign ministers from the UN general assembly to discuss women's rights. She does however have time in her schedule to shop for expensive shoes while poor people drown. It's all about priorities Ms. Rice. It is clear that yours lie not with the people (women, minorities, the underclass) but with the powerful. Ferragamoleezza is suffering from the same syndrome that every other member of the Bush administration is plagued by--isolation from reality. Until our government realizes what irreversible damage has been done to Iraq we will continue down the path of failure. When Bush says we are staying the course in Iraq it really means that he doesn't know what the hell he is doing and is too afraid to admit that he is wrong.
I can't offer any solutions to this mess. I don't know what's worse--pulling out all U.S. troops immediately or staying put and incurring more violence, death and chaos. I am not a military planner or a foreign policy specialist. What I can realize is that things aren't going well and if we don't change course we are doomed to failure. That's why I will be in Los Angeles this coming Saturday, September 24, to voice my opinions that we are headed in the wrong direction. My only hope is people will begin to talk more honestly and openly about Iraq and drop all this amphetamine-addicted parrot talk of "we're spreading freedom, we're spreading freedom, we're spreading freedom . . ."
condoleezza rice condi rice downing street memo impeach bush